Blender Wars: Immersion Blender vs Hand Mixer

Immersion blenders and hand mixers are pretty similar appliances used to carry out similar tasks. While being so very similar, however, the two are quite distinct, and while one can replace the other for some tasks, this is only sometimes the case. With the two being so similar, it’s a given that an immersion blender vs hand mixer comparison would come up. This article will be making that comparison, explaining the similarities, differences, and proper use cases of both appliances. 

Now with that said, let’s get to it!

What is an Immersion Blender?

Immersion blenders, also known as stick blenders or hand blenders, are handheld kitchen appliances used for blending and mixing ingredients in containers. These blenders do exactly what other kitchen blenders do. There’s just one difference; while the ingredients to be processed go into the two other types of blenders (countertop and personal blenders), the reverse is the case with immersion blenders; they go into the ingredients, hence their name.

Immersion blenders typically consist of a long, cylindrical motor body with a blade attachment at the bottom. The end with the blade is what is immersed directly into the ingredients or liquid to be processed, allowing the user to blend or puree the ingredients directly in the container. 

What is a Hand Mixer?

A hand mixer is a kitchen appliance used to mix and whip ingredients together. It typically consists of a small motor with two beaters attached to it. The beaters are designed to rotate in opposite directions to mix the ingredients evenly. 

Hand mixers are handheld instruments, just like immersion blenders, making them easy to use and maneuver in various-sized containers. They are ideal for mixing cake batter, whipping cream, and kneading dough. Hand mixers often come with multiple speed options, allowing users to adjust the speed to their needs. 

Hand Mixer Vs Immersion Blender

Similarities Between Hand Mixers and Immersion Blenders

As stated earlier, immersion blenders and hand mixers are quite similar appliances. Below are some of those similarities:

  1. Design: While hand mixers and immersion blenders don’t look alike, both appliances are handheld devices and have their handles on one end with the other end designed to be dipped into the ingredient. 
  2. Function: Both hand mixers and immersion blenders serve the purpose of blending, mixing, and whipping ingredients for great recipes.
  3. Ease of use: Both hand mixers and immersion blenders are quite easy to use, making them accessible to home cooks and professionals alike. 
  4. Versatility: Both hand mixers and immersion blenders can be used for a variety of tasks, from mixing cake batter to blending soups and sauces.
You might also find this article useful: Blender Wars: Vitamix 5300 vs e310

Difference Between Immersion Blenders and Hand Mixers

Although both appliances are hand-held and can be used interchangeably for a number of tasks, there are some differences to be noted between both. The major of these difference is what these appliances come attached with.

Hand mixers come attached with beaters which are designed for tasks such as mixing cake batter, whipping cream, kneading dough, and whisking eggs. Immersion blenders, on the other hand, have blade attachments instead of whisks. These blades are used for blending, pureeing, mixing, and so on. 

This difference in attachments is why immersion blenders are great at some things while hand mixers are better at others.

When Should You Use an Immersion Blender?

As stated earlier, immersion blenders are just like your regular blenders, the only difference being that they go into the ingredients instead of the other way around. So basically, you should use immersion blenders when you want to do anything you’d normally use your regular blender for, e.g

  • Making soups,
  • Blending smoothies, slushies, and shakes,
  • Preparing sauces,
  • Whipping heavy cream,
  • Mixing liquid ingredients,
  • Pureeing baby food, etc.

You might want to avoid using your immersion blender for blending tasks like crushing ice or blending dry ingredients, however, as the blades of these blenders are designed to better handle soft and wet ingredients. 

When Should You Use a Hand Mixer?

Hand mixers don’t have the blades you find on immersion blenders. Instead, they have whisks which are basically designed for mixing ingredients. Hence, your hand mixer is the perfect tool for carrying out tasks like;

  • Mixing two or more light ingredients together,
  • Whipping/whisking eggs and cream, 
  • Creaming fat and sugar, 
  • Folding light ingredients like egg whites into a batter, 
  • Mashing potatoes, etc.

It is essential to always bear in mind, however, that hand mixers are designed for carrying out only light mixing tasks. This is because most hand mixers do not come with very powerful motors. If you want to carry out more demanding mixing operations, a stand mixer would make a much better choice.

Can You Use Immersion Blenders and Hand Mixers Interchangeably?

In some cases, immersion blenders and hand mixers can be used interchangeably. That being said, they each excel at different things. When it comes to mixing, a hand mixer is the better of both appliances as it produces better consistency and gets the job done faster. Immersion blenders can still get the job done, hand mixers would be a better choice.

When it comes to things like blending fruits and making smoothies, slushies, and so on, the immersion blender is by far the better choice. Since hand mixers have no blades, they are not a good choice for the job. 

Hand Mixer Vs Immersion Blender: Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing between the two, it all depends on your personal preference. Here is our recommendation though. If you already have a countertop or personal blender in your kitchen but do not have a mixer, going for a hand mixer might be a better option. If you already have a hand mixer, however, or have none of them, choosing the immersion blender is a much better choice since your immersion blender can practically do what your hand mixer can, but your hand mixer can’t do some of the things your immersion blender can.

Blender Recommendation

Considering getting yourself an immersion blender? The Vitamix Immersion Blender is one of the best choices out there. This handheld blender comes with everything you need, including a whisk attachment which allows the blender to function exactly like a hand mixer, giving you value for two in just one device. You can get the Vitamix Immersion Blender for your kitchen.

Leave a Comment